Guide · International trade

Payment methods in international trade: who carries the risk

Short answer

The main payment methods in international trade are cash in advance, letters of credit, documentary collections and open account. They share the risk differently: cash in advance protects the exporter, open account favours the importer, and letters of credit and collections use banks and documents in between. The right choice depends on the relationship, country risk, amount and market practice.

Key points

  • Cash in advance removes the exporter’s risk of non-payment and leaves the importer exposed; open account does the opposite.
  • A letter of credit under UCP 600 is a bank’s undertaking to pay against complying documents; banks deal with documents, not with goods.
  • In a documentary collection under URC 522, banks pass the documents against payment (D/P) or acceptance (D/A) but do not undertake to pay.
  • Open account can be protected with credit insurance, a standby letter of credit, factoring or forfaiting, each at its own cost.
  • Methods can be combined, for example a deposit at order with the balance by letter of credit.
  • Verify any change of bank details by phone, on a number you already know, before you pay.

What are the main payment methods in international trade?

Every international sale has to settle who carries the risk between shipment and payment. The exporter wants to be paid before it loses control of the goods. The importer wants the goods, or at least proof of shipment, before it pays. Payment methods are ways of sharing that gap:

  • Cash in advance: the importer pays, in full or in part, before shipment.
  • Letter of credit: a bank undertakes to pay against documents that comply with its terms.
  • Documentary collection: banks exchange the shipping documents for payment or for an accepted bill of exchange, without undertaking to pay.
  • Open account: the exporter ships and the importer pays later, on an agreed due date.

None is good or bad in itself. Each places more of the risk on one side.

Cash in advance: full or partial

The importer pays by bank transfer before shipment, sometimes before production starts. The exporter’s risk of non-payment disappears. The importer is fully exposed: the money has left, and the goods, their quality and the delivery date depend on the supplier. Full prepayment is common for samples, small orders, made-to-order goods and new relationships.

A partial advance is a frequent middle ground: a deposit at order covers the supplier’s initial costs, and the balance is paid by another method.

An importer paying in advance can ask for security, such as an advance payment guarantee or a standby letter of credit issued by the supplier’s bank, which it can claim if the supplier does not deliver. Not every supplier will accept, and who bears the cost has to be agreed.

Letter of credit: a bank’s undertaking against documents

With a letter of credit (LC, or documentary credit), the importer’s bank, the issuing bank, undertakes to pay the exporter against documents that comply with the terms of the credit. Most LCs are issued subject to the ICC’s UCP 600, under which a credit is irrevocable.

The exporter relies on a bank’s undertaking rather than on the buyer’s promise. The importer pays only against the documents it asked for, such as a transport document and, if required, an independent inspection certificate. The limits:

  • Banks deal with documents, not with goods. An LC does not prove that the goods match the contract.
  • Discrepancies in the documents can delay payment or allow the issuing bank to refuse.
  • The exporter still depends on the issuing bank and its country. A bank in the exporter’s country can be asked to add its confirmation, its own undertaking to pay.
  • It is the most document-intensive and usually the most costly method, and the importer needs the issuing bank’s credit approval.

Documentary collection: D/P and D/A under URC 522

The exporter ships and hands the documents, usually with a bill of exchange (draft), to its bank, the remitting bank. That bank sends them with a collection instruction to a bank in the importer’s country, the collecting bank. Collections are usually subject to the ICC’s Uniform Rules for Collections (URC 522).

  • Documents against payment (D/P): the documents are released only when the importer pays. Without them, the importer usually cannot take delivery or clear customs.
  • Documents against acceptance (D/A): the documents are released when the importer accepts a bill of exchange, a commitment to pay on a set future date. The importer gets the goods first.

The banks act as intermediaries on the exporter’s instructions. They do not check whether the documents are accurate and do not undertake to pay. If the importer refuses a D/P collection, the exporter keeps the documents, but its goods sit in a foreign port: it may have to find another buyer, pay for return freight or abandon the cargo. Under D/A the exposure is greater, because the importer already has the goods.

D/P protection relies on a transport document that controls the goods, typically a bill of lading made out to order. Collections are generally simpler and cheaper than LCs, and suit established relationships in stable markets.

Preparing an import or export? Describe your need in a few lines. We reply within 24 hours on business days with questions and, if we can help, a proposal agreed in writing before any work starts.

Describe your need

Open account, and how it can be protected

The exporter ships and sends the documents directly to the importer, who pays by transfer on the agreed due date. It is the simplest and cheapest method and the most favourable to the importer. For the exporter, it means extending unsecured credit to a foreign buyer, so exporters often add protection:

  • Credit insurance: an insurer covers the buyer’s non-payment and, under some policies, political risks, within agreed limits.
  • A standby letter of credit issued by the importer’s bank as a payment guarantee, drawn only if the buyer does not pay.
  • Factoring: the exporter sells or assigns short-term receivables to a factor, which advances part of their value and collects from the buyer, with or without recourse.
  • Forfaiting: a forfaiter buys receivables, usually medium-term and often evidenced by bank-guaranteed or avalised bills or notes, typically without recourse.

Each depends on the provider’s own assessment and has its own cost. Consignment, where the exporter is paid only once the goods are resold, is riskier still for the exporter.

The risk ladder: how the methods compare

MethodWhen the exporter is paidRisk for the exporterRisk for the importerCost and complexity
Cash in advanceBefore shipmentLowestHighest: pays before receiving anythingLow: a bank transfer
Letter of creditOn a complying presentation, at sight or on a later fixed dateLow if the documents comply; lower still when confirmedLow to moderate: pays against documents, not against inspection of the goodsHighest: bank fees, credit approval, strict documents
Documentary collection D/PWhen the importer pays the collecting bankModerate: the buyer can refuse, leaving the goods abroadLow to moderate: pays before inspecting the goodsModerate: bank fees, fewer formalities than an LC
Documentary collection D/AAt maturity of the accepted billHigher: the buyer has the goods; the exporter holds a billLow: receives the goods before payingModerate
Open accountOn the agreed due date after shipmentHighest, unless protectedLowestLowest, plus the cost of any protection

The order is indicative. The real risk also depends on the parties, the banks, the countries and how carefully the documents are drafted.

How to choose and combine payment methods

The method is negotiated and usually depends on four factors:

  • The relationship. New counterparties tend to start with more secure methods; terms loosen as a track record builds.
  • Country risk. Political instability, foreign exchange controls or transfer restrictions in the buyer’s country push the exporter towards advance payment or an LC, confirmed if needed.
  • Amount and term. The larger the sale and the longer the credit period, the more a bank instrument’s cost is justified.
  • Market practice. In some sectors and countries open account is standard; elsewhere LCs or collections are expected.

Example (illustrative): an importer buying production machinery pays a deposit at order and the balance by a letter of credit payable against the bill of lading and an inspection certificate. Other combinations include a deposit with the balance by D/P, or open account backed by a standby or credit insurance.

The payment clause should match the rest of the contract: the Incoterm (see Incoterms® 2020), the documents, the currency, the due dates and the bank charges. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Fraud, sanctions and bank checks at the payment stage

A frequent payment fraud involves no forged instrument. A criminal gains access to, or imitates, the supplier’s email and announces new bank details. The importer pays the new account and the money is lost. This is business email compromise (BEC). Red flags:

  • a change of bank or account announced by email, especially shortly before a payment;
  • an account in a country or a name that differs from the supplier’s;
  • a sender address or domain slightly different from the usual one;
  • pressure to pay urgently or confidentially.

Verify any change of payment details by phone, on a number you already know or have found independently, never one given in the message. Check the supplier itself before the first payment (see supplier due diligence). If you have paid a fraudulent account, contact your bank immediately.

Payments and documents must also comply with the sanctions and export control rules that apply to the parties and the banks. Banks screen the parties, countries, goods and sometimes vessels, and run their own know-your-customer checks. They may delay or decline a transaction that raises a concern, whatever payment method was agreed.

How Star Alliance helps

Star Alliance is an advisory and facilitation firm: it is not a bank and does not hold client funds. Our import-export transaction review looks at the contract, the payment terms and the counterparties, and identifies the points to settle before you commit. Where a letter of credit, standby or guarantee is needed, it is handled through our trade finance instruments service. Scope and terms are agreed in writing before any work starts, and the final decision on any instrument belongs to the issuing institution.

Frequently asked questions

Which payment method is safest for an exporter?

Cash in advance removes the risk of non-payment. Among bank-based methods, a letter of credit gives the strongest protection, particularly when a bank in the exporter’s country confirms it, provided the documents presented comply with its terms.

Which payment method is safest for an importer?

Open account, because the importer pays after receiving the goods. With a supplier it does not yet know, a letter of credit lets the importer pay only against agreed documents, such as a transport document and an independent inspection certificate.

What is the difference between a documentary collection and a letter of credit?

Under a letter of credit, the issuing bank undertakes to pay against complying documents. Under a documentary collection, the banks only release the documents against payment or acceptance: they do not check the documents for accuracy and do not undertake to pay. Collections are simpler and usually cheaper, but leave more risk with the exporter.

What is the difference between D/P and D/A?

Under documents against payment (D/P), the importer obtains the documents only by paying. Under documents against acceptance (D/A), it obtains them by accepting a bill of exchange and pays at maturity, so the exporter is extending credit until that date.

Can a supplier ask for a deposit and a letter of credit for the balance?

Yes. A partial advance combined with a letter of credit for the balance is a recognised structure. The deposit covers the supplier’s initial costs, and the importer pays the larger part only against documents showing shipment.

Sources

  1. International Trade Administration (trade.gov) — Trade Finance Guide: Methods of Payment
  2. International Trade Administration (trade.gov) — Documentary Collections
  3. ICC Academy — Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600)
  4. ICC Academy — URC 522: Uniform Rules for Collections, including eURC Version 1.1
  5. FBI — Business Email Compromise

Star Alliance Consulting editorial team · Updated 16 November 2026

Preparing an import or export?

Describe your need in a few lines. We reply within 24 hours on business days with questions and, if we can help, a proposal agreed in writing before any work starts.

Or write to us at info@starallianceconsult.com

Describe your need
WhatsApp